The final time Williams recruited a key Mercedes determine to a number one function in its Method 1 workforce, it didn’t finish properly.
New Williams workforce principal James Vowles’ change from Mercedes, the place he performed a distinguished function in its run of titles from 2014-2021, has echoes of Paddy Lowe’s transfer forward of the 2017 season.
Lowe joined Williams as its chief technical officer having held the place of government director (technical) at Mercedes and, as one of the vital revered senior technical figures in F1 on the time, represented a serious coup for Williams.
He left the workforce barely two years later within the wake of its disastrous begin to the 2019 season with a automobile that was delayed and that missed the beginning of testing, initially had unlawful elements on it, then was dreadfully uncompetitive.
There have been loads of tales early in 2019 indicating Lowe was ill-suited to such a senior place having excelled in additional particular roles earlier than that, as Lowe was shortly painted because the villain of the piece by the Williams hierarchy.
No matter his limitations could have been, he was clearly not the one downside. Williams’s long-running malaise and deep-rooted points go properly past one particular person and that has continued within the Dorilton period that started in late 2020.
However there was a transparent narrative on the time that Williams felt that it’d had the wool pulled over its eyes in signing Lowe. What had regarded like an awesome alternative was later interpreted as Mercedes simply easing out somebody it might probably not miss.
Cynically, Vowles’ transfer might be seen in the identical mild: a hand-me-down who Mercedes is simply letting go as a result of, finally, it has determined it could actually afford to.
However Vowles’ earlier place at Mercedes is the very best proof to counter that. Although he held a really senior place within the workforce he was additionally a key member of Wolff’s inside circle. He was an advisor, a “sparring accomplice” to borrow considered one of Wolff’s favorite phrases, and a trusted ally.
Mercedes will nonetheless really feel Vowles will be changed however he had a rock-solid place and has not been eased in the direction of the exit door in any respect. As a substitute, he was focused by Williams after it axed Jost Capito in December.
That could be a key distinction between Williams recruiting him from Mercedes in comparison with Lowe, who had been earmarked for an exit by Wolff – who actively wished to exchange him and alter the management construction.
You could or could not consider Vowles to be an infinite loss for the technique workforce, for Mercedes’ broader path, or for Wolff personally. However he was a key a part of the set-up.
And that’s in all probability the very best argument for why he’s removed from a Mercedes hand-me-down: it’s much less to do with the precise function he had and extra to do along with his standing and the way satisfied Wolff was by Vowles as a part of his management workforce.
Vowles wouldn’t have had that accountability, been relied on by Wolff to assist with key choices for the workforce, and been a supervisor of individuals if day-to-day he didn’t lead by instance. That’s one thing Wolff has all the time demanded of Mercedes’ senior figures. In any other case, they don’t final.
Tradition is one thing that Williams appears to have lacked for a really very long time. In becoming a member of as workforce principal, considered one of Vowles’ primary duties can be discovering the place the rot actually begins and making no matter progress he can to enhance the state of affairs.
The final particular person to maneuver from Mercedes to Williams in a senior place had the identical intention. Williams will hope that’s the place the similarities start and finish.
Thanks to your suggestions!